Jump to content

4WD Issues


MarkieMark

Recommended Posts

Hi Guys,

 

Looking for some guidance...

I have a 2015 golf R DSG with 60K miles. I had the Haldex serviced by VW in December last year and no problems reported. I then had a stage 1 map done in Jan and immediately noticed loads of front wheel spin. This was possibly happening before but probably hadn't driven it hard for a while so not noticed. I popped back to the garage that had done the stage one and they hooked it up to their diagnostics and diagnosed Haldex pump failure, this was replaced and they said all was good, but the wheel spin still remained. with ESC on in first and second if I floor it the ESC Light just goes mad and the car bogs down in the first 2 gears. in ESC sport mode the front wheels just spin, 1st is unusable and 2nd is not much better! I've since read just about every post on the internet but still have questions and cant really find a post that covers the whole drive train and also the relationship between the various other systems such as ESC & ESC sport, ABS etc.

 

I appreciate there has to be a limit to physical grip but reading loads of posts, sounds like I should be able to get the power down without all this wheel spin even with the stage 1!

 

Q. I understand the Haldex system and how it transfers up to 50% torque to the rear. my question is about the bit before that, there must be some sort of from diff that splits the power between the front and rear drive shafts, are the front and rear drive shafts always spinning at the same speed? lets assume the Haldex doesn't exist and it's a solid drive shaft to the rear diff would my front and rear wheels be turning at the same speed in a straight line or say for instance my front wheels are on ice and my back wheels where on dry tarmac would my front wheels just spin or are the drive shafts fixed so they must turn at the same speed so my gripping back wheels would just push me forward? you can probable tell from this I'm not mechanical! I'm sure this is a stupid question but from a non mechanical guy I'm thinking it's possible for the inner and out wheels on the same axel to spin at different speeds when cornering so I'm applying that logic and thinking it may be possible for front and rear wheels to spin at different speeds. The other half of my brain is shouting well that would defeat the point of 4 wheel drive, but I'm asking it anyway please don't be too patronising...

I think what I'm trying to get at is if the front and rear axles must spin at the same speed then it would be impossible to spin the front wheels and not the back at the same time so in my case points back to the Haldex system still not functioning correctly.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Unless it's wet and your tyres are bald then you shouldn't experiencing too much wheelspin. I'm stage 2 and very rarely get any wheelspin. Only a bit of esc intervention when I've got some lock on or the camber of the road confuses the esc.

 

Who did the pump change? A main dealer? As it needs priming according to the haldex folks.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

As you have a new Haldex pump already I'd be suspicious of the transfer case/bevel box.  This has a large gear inside that is only pressed onto the shaft, and sometimes this gear can spin on the shaft.  This is more commonly a problem on cars that have used Launch Control a lot (LC puts a lot of pressure on all the drive train components). 

 

This particular fault can be tricky to diagnose because the gear only slips when under a lot of pressure (eg hard takeoff).  One way to tell is to put the car up on a hoist, engine off, put the gearbox in D (or 1st if manual) and try to turn the propshaft to the rear axle (you'll need a very large pair of multi-grips or similar so you can apply a LOT of torque to the propshaft).  If it turns then you have the slipping gear problem.  Many people replace the transfer case/bevel box with a used one from another R.

 

If it won't turn then I'd revisit the complete Haldex system (including the controller).

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Hi Guys,

 

Thank's for you responses and advice. I think I need to get it back to the garage, the guys that did the Haldex pump are the same guys that did the stage 1 and specialise in VW & Audi so I guess I'll have to put my trust in their hands. I've also got a 4WD  dyno session booked, I guess that may show how bad the issue is. 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I had my transfer box let go a week or 2 after I had a stage 2 done. I guess the extra power and however many launched Its had in its past life would have contributed. 
 

Mine was pretty obvious to diagnose, with all

4 wheels off the ground, my prop-shaft wouldn’t spin. Only realised after getting a new pump. 
 

As @golf7.5r mentioned, its worth doing the pump prime on VCDS, and try a couple launches after this to see if your AWD module brings up a fault. I remember getting “awd mechanical failure” 

 

 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • 2 weeks later...

Update on my previous post may be of interest?

 

I purchased my self the OBDeleven recently and when I plugged it in sure enough I had a "All Wheel drive (AWD mechanical malfunction) fault code C111307 intermittent". doing some reading and found a really good site https://www.haldexrepairs.co.uk/generation-5-haldex-fault-finding-repair-guide/  I narrowed it down to front transfer box shot (expensive) or Haldex pump issue(cheaper). I've already replaced the pump so I know that's good and reading the website it mentioned that a common problem is garages not running the pump learn function after replacement so the control module still has the old values from the old blocked or failed pump so the new one never works properly.

It is possible to run the pump learn function from the OBDeleven but it's not obvious ( I did this on my ios device):-

Open control module 22 AWD > Basic Settings > Pump motor 

you should then bee looking at the pump motor with Status "not active" and a pump motor drop down menu and the green activation slider at the bottom (you need the engine running) I then selected the pump motor drop down menu there is only one option in here "All adaption Values" I selected this and pressed start. I knelt down by the car and could here the Haldex pump running, if the learn function has initiated properly you will hear the pump speeding up as it ramps up the pressure to the 42bar pressure relief and then drops down, it does this a few times it took approximately 55 seconds and the process completed automatically.

Following the learn function I checked the Pump calibration values in the live data section and had all 0's which I believe is normal following calibration, I then took the car for a short drive and the grip feels much better with hardly any wheel spin when I got back I had to turn of the ignition and back on again for the calibrations values to update but they look good for a healthy pump, see table below.


 

 

1 bar 

15 bar 

42 bar 

mV

2148

4822

7255

mA

2024

5611

10219


I have done a few hard accelerations now in the lower gears and the extra grip is really noticeable and the fault code has not reappeared, fingers crossed!!

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Nice result - glad you avoided an expensive fix in the end. Bit of a shame the garage, being a "VW and Audi specialist" (though I see so many garages call themselves that) didn't run the 'pump learn' - I'd probably feed that back to them for future reference.

 

Do you get any wheel spin now @MarkieMark? My R is stock and I only get slippage when either - a. The car is cold and I'm guessing the Haldex oil needs some warming or b. I'm turning out of a T-junction (not full lock, but most of the rack) which the Haldex doesn't like so it spins up.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Hi Ignition1

 

I get very little wheel spin now even with stage 1, the traction light comes on occasionally dependent on road surface wheel angle etc. but in essence on a dry flat piece of tarmac and ESC in sport, from a standing start it just goes with no wheel spin.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

Loading...
×
×
  • Create New...